Akron Beacon Journal
Editorial, 3/26/2004
Rather
than resist lower levels of mercury emissions, the Bush administration
would do well to support them ried to find a mercury thermometer
lately? If they seem elusive, there's a reason. Mercury is a T known
toxin, particularly damaging to the nervous system. Because of its
dangerous qualities, most industrial uses of mercury have been severely
restricted. However, mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants
-- Ohio is a leader in air pollution from power plants -- remain
virtually unregulated.
That
began to change during the 1990s, after a successful lawsuit against
the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency by the Natural Resources
Defense Council. In 1998, courts ordered the EPA to determine by
December 2004 deadlines for reducing power-plant emissions of specific
toxic materials. The goal is to cut mercury emissions by 90 percent.
However,
last December, the Bush administration astonished the environmental
community by deciding that mercury should not be regulated as a
toxic substance. The determination paved the way for an industry-supported,
market-based solution that critics charge needlessly jeopardizes
public health.
Bush's
"Clear Skies Initiative" permits cleaner-operating power
plants, if they meet acceptable levels for such pollutants as sulfur
dioxide and nitrogen oxide, to trade pollution credits with dirty
power plants. The new rule would enable such credit trading for
mercury as well.
Unfortunately,
environmental testing has shown that mercury does not travel in
the atmosphere nearly as far as other compounds. Instead, it creates
mercury "hot spots" in regions immediately surrounding
coal-fired power plants.
The
Bush administration is playing a dangerous game by downplaying mercury's
toxicity. Children and pregnant or nursing women are advised not
to eat certain kinds of fish because of their high mercury content.
Mercury contamination has been linked to birth defects and developmental
delays in children exposed to the heavy metal. A recent study by
the National Wildlife Federation found that mercury-laden rain concentrates
contamination in rivers and streams instead of diluting it. More,
bacterial action on mercury makes it even more toxic.
EPA
Director Michael Leavitt, responding to protests over the new rules,
has ordered a new round of studies, yet it is doubtful new studies
will show mercury to be any less a threat to human health.
Instead,
the EPA should push toward rules that will meet the December deadline
imposed by the courts. The technology exists to reduce mercury emissions
substantially. American Electric Power and Cinergy have begun to
address the threat. Other power companies and the Bush administration
should follow their lead, not walk backward.
[TOP]
|